Editor’s Note: Michelle Moreau is the Director of James Madison University’s Communication Resource Center where she coordinates presentational speaking tutoring programs. She has taught public speaking at the university level for several years.
Graduations are weird.
Life before noon begins with them, timeless ceremonies replicated on thousands of college campuses each year marking the transition between college and the rest of your life. Those readers who have recently walked, will walk in the next couple of weeks, or did so years ago, probably approach this ceremony with high expectations for that life altering moment when throngs of family, friends and teachers witness your rebirth onto an exhilarating path to adulthood.
But for many, graduation fails to provide the Dawson Creek-esque scene they have imagined through the years.
It would be easy to blame the heat or the uncomfortable robes, the endless series of pomp and circumstance, the tassels that fly into your lipgloss and stick or even the tedious graduation speakers. (They are bad. This year, our keynote speaker made us all hold hands while the sound system pumped inspirational music over the sweaty crowd. Really? Really?)
Take it from me, a professor and graduation ceremony veteran, the answer to “why am I not enjoying this,” like the last question on your microeconomics final, is not simple. It involves dissonance. Remember dissonance? A concept drawn from the music field, borrowed throughout the social sciences that posits when discordant elements clash-musical notes, for example-they produce some sort of a negative result. Well, in this case, our inharmonious notes are:
- Your home away from home-your college campus
- Your family, heretofore not a part of your college home
- Your college family, friends and faculty who have cared for you through your years of higher education
Simply put, graduation is the first but not the last time in your life when you introduce your primary and most important caregivers, your parents and family, to the new life that you are leading without them. Before you left for college they were an important part of your everyday life, now at graduation they become tourists eyeing the monuments of your last few years of maturation. And without being able to put your finger on it, graduation seems to be less about you and more about working to integrate all the parts of you into a whole score.
And it’s a lot of work. Getting family from point A to point B easily is like getting the registrar to send your transcripts for free. It ain’t gonna happen, give it up. Honestly, families invade campus like a bunch of helpless children on graduation day. Walking slowly, pointing and snapping lots of pictures. Seriously, you’ve never seen an oak tree that big? Seriously?
Another thing, faculty and family don’t mix well. Both groups are authority figures, after all, accustomed to a measure of respect. Take for example, an exchange I had with a father during our college ceremony this May.
I was in the middle of a conversation with a fellow professor. We didn’t know where we were supposed to sit. A father barges into our conversation, “Oh, so you’ve been to one of these before. How long is it going to last? It’s getting hot out here.” I glared at him. He had just asked the dad-equivalent of, “Is this going to be on the test?”
I wanted to say, “Look, baldy boy, I care enough about your son or daughter to be here in this hot robe. Sit down and quit gettin’ your knickers in a wad,” but didn’t. He is a guest on campus and that whole holding hands thing was traumatic for all of us.
I patiently began explaining quadratic equation that is a graduation ceremony: time = speakers’ rate of speech + speed of students filing across the stage x number of students/number of students who trip. Bored, daddy-o cuts me off mid-explanation with, “Are you a professor? My daughter’s Ashley. Do you know her?”
We have three hundred majors graduating that day. I don’t know his Ashley. Daddy-o looks at me like I am a total waste of his tuition dollars. I consider docking his class participation points for the day.
But let’s say I did know Ashley and Ashley introduced us. I would smile and say, “You have a terrific daughter, Mr. Huffy-Pants (I wouldn’t really call him that). She has a bright future ahead of her. You should be proud.” This is after all why faculty attend. Our last act of affection for our students is to tell their parents out loud what the parents really know anyway. And Mr. Huffy-Pants would thank me and launch into a story about Ashley’s childhood, probably designed to embarrass her. All the while Ashley is standing in her hot robe thinking, “I don’t know where I’m going to be living in two weeks and at the moment I’m responsible for getting the whole family to Cally’s before they give our table to someone else.” Dissonance, my friends, is staring down the rest of your life with a tassel swinging in the corner of your vision.
Ashley will survive graduation day. And she will find a place to live and a meaningful career. Her teachers and family share some of the credit for that, but Ashley deserves to revel in the feeling of accomplishment that comes with transitioning from college into life. The customary authors of this cite are hopefully off doing some of that right now. While their parents haul them and their stuff off to exotic new locals, they asked folks like me to guest post.
Smart idea, huh? I wonder where they learned that.